| Home / College Guide / The Prophet and the Host |
| Posted on Tuesday, November 03 @ 00:00:29 PST |

Russ Roberts recorded his conversation with Jordan Peterson on January 25, 2018, two days after 12 Rules for Life came out and the day it reached number one on Amazon. Listeners wrote afterward asking why he had not challenged his guest. Two months later he answered them in “What I’ve Learned from Jordan Peterson,” and the essay is more revealing than the episode, because in it Roberts describes his own method as if from outside and then declines to change it.
The episode first. Roberts introduced the book as “the only self-help book that combines the Bible, Nietzsche, Dostoevsky, Jung, and a lot of Jordan Peterson,” and said he had found it “provocative, inspiring, sometimes frustrating” (0:56). Peterson: “I found it frustrating too, so you’re not alone there.” The opening question was about happiness, and Peterson’s answer set the register for the hour: people who say they want to be happy “mean they don’t wanna be anxious and in pain,” happiness is “a gift,” and “the idea that somehow the default position of human beings is happiness is just, it’s the delusion of an extremely naive child” (1:36 to 4:30). Roberts offered David Foster Wallace’s “everyone worships” and the caution that we should choose carefully what we attach ourselves to (4:57).
Peterson answered with Columbine and the serial killer Carl Panzram, “people can go to very dark places because they become bitter and resentful and then they can align themselves with the desire to do harm” (5:50). That is the exchange in miniature: Roberts brings Smith and Wallace, Peterson brings the abyss, and Roberts nods.
Roberts’s favorite Smith line arrived at 10:43, “Man naturally desires not only to be loved, but to be lovely,” and Peterson turned it into a clinical instruction. Watch the eyes and face of the person you are talking to: “You want their eyes to be open and their pupils to be slightly dilated… all of that is broadcasting that you’re acting in a lovely manner in Adam Smith’s sense of the term” (12:40). Roberts answered with a confession about his own trade: “some of the most transcendent moments of my life have been the handful of times I’ve had a conversation where that kind of connection is established with a person who might be almost sometimes a stranger… it’s a delicious thing” (14:10). Peterson cited his own rule nine, assume the person you are listening to knows something you don’t, and called such a conversation one “where the logos is present” (15:00).
Two men praising conversation to each other on a podcast is the EconTalk form at its purest, and it is the moment the host is least likely to push.
The parenting section was the warmest. Roberts raised Bryan Caplan’s twin studies, which find that parents have little lasting effect, and Peterson dismissed them on grounds that the statistics “aren’t sufficiently sophisticated to pick up the individuality of what you’re doing” (19:00). Roberts: “I happen to agree with you and I happen to agree with that general thrust on social science research generally” (19:24). He had sent the book to his father for the rule “Don’t let your children do anything that makes you dislike them,” which was his father’s philosophy too (19:35). Peterson’s defense of the rule is the best passage of the hour. It is “the rule that you would adopt if you knew that you were a monster,” and “when I had my little kids… I’d already recognized that I was a monster,” so “I can’t allow them to disturb me deeply because I will definitely take my revenge if they do” (20:10 to 21:30). A child whose behavior is regulated enters “a world where when adults see them and smile, they mean it” (23:00).
Roberts, at sixty-three with four children and the youngest eighteen, added that loving them means accepting “those flaws that are your flaws and that you’ve created. You’ve created them genetically, you’ve created them through the household behaviors and you still love them” (24:35). Peterson quoted Nietzsche, “Great men are seldom credited with their stupidity,” and said a flaw is often “the flip side of a virtue.”
Roberts had one complaint and made it gently. The book is “a little short on joy and love, I would call it a stern book” (27:06), and “I’m just curious why you focus so much on what I would call the dark side of the human heart.” Peterson: “it’s a corrective… everyone knows it, but no one will talk about it” (27:30). He had talked to thousands of people, and when he says “life is fundamentally tragic and ridden with suffering… it’s a relief to people because they think, oh my God, I thought I was supposed to be happy” (28:30). And the Columbine shooters, he added, “have powerful arguments.” Roberts let that one go by.
Then the passage that explains the essay to come. Roberts quoted Smith on the man of system, who “thinks he can manipulate human beings as if they were pieces on a chessboard,” and said it was “deeply consonant with your rule that we should fix ourselves before we fix others” (30:19).
He went on: “I find myself less interested in reading the news, trying to influence the debate… I don’t feel the need to rant, say, about the latest policy blunder the way I used to. And I’m increasingly humble about what I’m sure of. So that’s all good” (30:41). Then the worry: the Western experiment that “celebrates and honors liberty, restrains the power of the state, recognizes the sanctity of the individual, that that’s in jeopardy, maybe serious jeopardy,” and “I see your book and your videos as a part of an effort to fight against that serious tide.” He asked for advice “on how to balance tending one’s own garden with the chaos that seems to be erupting outside.” Peterson’s answer was that Roberts might be working “at exactly the right level of resolution,” since “moving beyond your domain of immediate competence would be grandiose and destructive,” though the failure to go further might also be “a consequence of cowardice and ignorance” (33:05). He said he was “torn about it” himself, having been drawn into politics by Canada’s compelled-speech bill, because “now and then the political becomes so unstable that it necessarily intrudes into the local” (34:40).
The host asked the prophet for permission to stay in his garden, and received it, with a footnote about cowardice that he did not take up.
On the universities Roberts was closer to his guest than to his usual self. Peterson called them “absolute disasters” where “80% of humanities papers now go uncited” (35:40) and told the Lindsay Shepherd story, the teaching assistant hauled before two professors and an administrator for showing a five-minute clip of Peterson on television, who taped the meeting and released it (36:40). Roberts’s response was to sharpen the metaphor: “it reminded me more of a communist or a Soviet re-education session than a Spanish Inquisition, if I could just make a subtle distinction there” (37:25). He had friends at Google who said the same of their workplace, “which I find it’s startling to hear,” and then, catching himself, “it is for sure it exaggerates because it’s really nothing like a Soviet reeducation camp in many dimensions, but it is alarming our unease, cultural unease with honest speech” (37:56). On student loans he found the economist’s version of Peterson’s “indentured servants” line: subsidized loans “allowed demand to increase, pushed up prices and allow those administrators to collect more money,” and “we’ve subsidized my industry, education, dramatically” (42:40).
The one place he pushed back on the universities was mild: uncited papers might go uncited because “a lot of it just doesn’t sell anyway, even when it’s well cited” (41:29).
The economics of the book is Peterson’s theory of sacrifice, which Roberts called “a very beautiful idea” (44:36). Cain and Abel dramatize the discovery “that you could give up something of value in the present and obtain something of greater value in the future, that you could bargain with the future” (46:00). God, in this reading, is “something like the future community,” and the kill shared with other hunters is saved “in the form of your enhanced reputation as a good person” (48:30). “It’s the discovery of the future itself, it’s the most profound discovery of humankind.” Roberts supplied the footnote that Keynes “blames the idea of savings on the Jews and blames the idea of the future on the Jews and views it as a bad thing” (50:25), and Peterson noted that “in the long run, we’re all dead” can “be used to justify absolutely anything” (51:50). Roberts: “I always wanna say, yeah, but my kids aren’t, I hope.”
Roberts warned that many of his listeners are “atheists intellectually and talking about the Bible probably gives them the willies” (52:09), and asked Peterson to explain reading it for non-religious reasons.
Peterson: “it’s not literally true in the way that scientific theories are true. It’s a story, it’s a story and it’s true the same way that Dostoevsky is true, except maybe it’s more true” (52:55). Order spoken out of chaos by the logos is good; people made in God’s image can speak order out of potential; “it’s time to stop being naive about the Bible for the fundamentalists and for the atheists alike” (55:00). Roberts, who runs his life by that book, accepted the Jungian account of it without a word about the other account. He recommended de Botton’s How Proust Can Change Your Life as the model for reading literature, and Faulkner’s “human heart in conflict with itself” (58:09), and on chaos and order he gave the summary he wished they had time for: “you can’t live in chaos, but if you live only in order, you’re not really alive” (1:01:00).
The last fifteen minutes were about fame, and here Roberts asked his hardest questions. He had never heard of Peterson until a year before, when “more than one person said I should interview you,” and now “when I mention to people that you’re going to be on this program, they say, oh, great. Or they’ll complain.
They say, I shouldn’t give you a forum because you’re a pawn of the alt right, which I find somewhat inexplicable” (1:04:04). Why the nerve? Peterson: “I hit it with a hammer.” He had set himself “in loud, continual and intense opposition on all fronts against the radical left,” and “there’s no difference between equality of outcome and tyranny. They’re the same thing” (1:06:13). It is convenient for the left to call him a Nazi, “because if I’m a Nazi, then they don’t have to take me seriously,” and he has “about 100 hours” of lectures on the Nazi death camps (1:07:30). The rest of the explanation was testimonials: the young man at the London School of Economics who had been “in a pretty dark place,” the strangers who stop him to say the lectures worked (1:08:40). “I’m a good aggregator of ideas, and I have my original thoughts.”
Roberts: “Now, how’s that humility thing working for you when you get a couple of people like that and you feel like you’ve got all the research on your side and all the wisdom of the past, doesn’t that, you have any issues with hubris?” (1:10:42). Peterson answered with Jung’s warning about Icarus, that in the archetypal domain “you don’t confuse yourself with the archetypes because you will burn yourself up if you do,” and “I am not confusing myself with the wisdom that I’m fortunate enough to be able to speak about” (1:11:15).
Roberts pressed from the other side: “for a lot of people, you are a breath of fresh air and for other people, you’re a toxic piece of pollution” (1:12:18). Peterson: “there’s a lot more of the first people than there are of the second people. I’ve only got about five pieces of hate mail. And I’ve got at least 25,000 letters in the last six months” (1:12:36). His opponents “very rarely take the time to actually understand what I’m doing.” He described his life as “surfing a hundred foot wave,” trying “not to drown and not do anything stupid and not say anything unforgivable” (1:14:22). And at the end, unprompted, the admission that he has “had experiences of severe depression, although I think I have that under control,” that he is fifty-five and a grandparent, and “I don’t think I’m in any particular danger of letting it go to my head. I’m too aware of what a vicious turn it could take” (1:16:36). Roberts’s parting advice, borrowed from the guest: “aim high.”
So the listeners had a point. Across seventy-eight minutes the host disagreed about the book’s mood and about nothing else. He agreed about social science, about the universities, about egalitarianism, about the Bible as story, about sacrifice.
He asked about hubris and accepted Jung as an answer. He never asked about the pronoun fight that made Peterson famous, or about the lobster, or about any of the clips his listeners sent. The Medium essay explains why, and the explanation is the most self-aware document in the Roberts archive.
He begins with the listeners. The interview “was on the book,” which “didn’t have very many of those fill-in-the-blank passages that offend people,” and “to cherry-pick the three or four times he said something offensive seems a bit strange” when Peterson has hundreds of hours online. That is the guest-respect rule from the thousandth episode, applied in advance: a man he respects gets the book conversation, and the controversial material waits for a second visit that never came. Then he says what he learned, and the first lesson is political. “Peterson reminded me that civilization is fragile.” He confesses that he voted for Gary Johnson and “found myself rooting for Hillary” on election night, that “very little that has happened since that night has changed my mind,” and then, “After watching Peterson, I started to wonder whether I had underestimated the threat of four more years of Obama-lite.
” Not on policy, “but on the cultural front.” He describes a panel of “the gentle left,” “a smugfest,” whose members “were like fish in water unable to imagine what water is.” “The left is everywhere. You don’t have to take a trip to Kentucky or to a church to understand the left.” Peterson “stands athwart that radical egalitarian agenda” and “refuses to say that 2+2 = 5.” The left hates him because “the left holds the moral high ground. They’ve lapped the field and can see the checkered flag. And what the heck is that cop car doing parked sideways as the left comes down the final straightaway?”
Then the balance, delivered on schedule. “Of course, Peterson’s talk of the Gulag and Auschwitz is grossly unfair to much of the progressive agenda.” “Trump and the right are also dangerous. I think Peterson understands that, too. If he doesn’t, he should.” Every paragraph that leans one way gets a sentence leaning back. The structure is the EconTalk structure in prose: a strong claim, a hedge, a strong claim, a hedge, until the reader from any coalition can find his own sentence.
The second lesson is literary. Peterson sent him to The Brothers Karamazov, “a big hole in my reading history,” and he asked his parents to mail him his college Nietzsche, and he may reread Jung and Solzhenitsyn and “even read some Freud.
” “Before encountering Peterson, I couldn’t imagine writing that previous sentence.” Three future EconTalk guests are announced in one paragraph: Jonah Goldberg, John Gray, Iain McGilchrist, the last two Peterson’s recommendations. A host who has just explained that he did not challenge a guest because he respects him now books the guest’s reading list. The essay is a conversion narrative in the small, and it names what converted him: a man who speaks with certainty.
That is the passage to keep. “There are some scary things about him. The near certainty with which he expresses himself is a huge part of his appeal, I suspect, but that kind of certainty is dangerous in its own way. His seeming confidence in his mission rubs me the wrong way.” Then the turn. “But I have to concede that there is a danger in my epistemological humility, my eagerness to confess my uncertainty. I am so glad to be increasingly able to say I don’t know. But perhaps this is a time for some intellectual risk-taking. That requires a certain level of overconfidence I no longer aspire to. I even have trouble respecting it. But one more thing I have learned from Peterson is how refreshing it is to see someone stand up and speak their mind without fear of the personal consequences.
That’s what prophets do.”
Read that as a man describing two market positions. Peterson sells certainty, and the certainty is “a huge part of his appeal.” Roberts sells doubt, and he has come to like it: “I am so glad to be increasingly able to say I don’t know,” the same pleasure he described in How Adam Smith Can Change Your Life as “an acquired taste… a dish best served hot.” He sees that each position is an appeal, sees that his own has a cost, names the cost as a reluctance to take intellectual risks, and then declines the risk. He does not say what he would say if he spoke without fear of the personal consequences. He says that watching someone else do it is refreshing. The whole apparatus of the show, the guest vetting, the book-only interview, the deferred second visit, the hedge after every lean, is on display in an essay whose author can see all of it and calls the alternative prophecy, which is to say, someone else’s job.
Roberts had the prophet on his own program and asked him, on air, how the humility thing was working out. Peterson answered with a myth. The host had no follow-up, because the host’s answer to the same question is the show.
|
|
| |
|